notthewayitssupposedtobeAaron has a particular agitation about circular arguments in theology.  He sat down for our discussion of chapter 1 of Not the Way It’s Supposed to Be repeating an argument he had already made via email.  “Sin is anti-shalom and shalom is the absence of sin?  This is like saying 2 plus 2 is 4, and then you take away a 2 and you are back at 2.  You haven’t done anything.”

Plantinga is tasked with providing the reader An Answer, so he shies away from the more nuanced issue of just how sin as a classification of things related to conscience and as a classification of things related to ethics works, or doesn’t.

The good stuff is hiding in a list of references in end-note 20.   In this following discussions I lean on the end-note 20 references, but also in particular on British author Iris Murdock’s Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals.

Using conscience as a higher form of self to deal with sin as a higher form of ethics seems to conveniently wrap up the issue. It maintains the personal connection with God while at the same time making sin a type of ethics (presuming our consciences will come to roughly similar conclusions about right behavior) measurable through reason.  You can measure this level of intent against the level of outcome and come to some legalistic conclusion about the measure of sin- a model Plantinga walks the reader through in chapter one.  This isn’t a uniquely American moral approach, but it is a particularly American approach.

In this model, judging is wrong because your measuring sticks are imperfect, not because there may be something intrinsically nonsensical about judging sin. Plantinga acknowledges there is some kind of mismatch between the measure and the thing- despite being lost we still make the measure because “we fear the softness of self-deception more than the hardness of accusation.” (p. 24) Christian anarchist Jacques Ellul presents a less forgiving take on the argument in The Technological Society: Once you hand the measure of your relationship to God over to the economic machinery you will never be able to get it back.

If you create a structure where sin is a matter of conscience, which is inarguably the mode of Christianity in the United States, you must also create a rule-bound structure to preserve ethics. Perversely, the more you lean on conscience the more rules you need to protect the world from the boundlessness of ego. Are we all existentialists now?  Murdock comments on existentialism: “I wouldn’t call that bravery, it’s just an egoistic gamble.” (p. 232)

Also, the more sin leans on conscience for definition, the less religion differs from non-religion. The philosopher Brian Leiter has seized upon this fact, recently publishing a book making the argument that the conscience of the religious person should count for no more than the conscience of a non-religious person (and that both should be subject to rule). From a civil perspective it is difficult to formulate any argument against that, though the idea of conscience being subject to law is heart-breaking.

Those similar conclusions about the right behavior?  Not so frequently the outcome. Consequently, Plantinga is moved to state that “serious Christians” view these rules as primary to conscience (p. 17) despite returning later to the primacy of conscience for one’s connection to a personal God.

Conscience as a particular development from Christian cosmology? A person making positive moral choices is no more driven toward Trinitarianism than anyone else.  Using Bertrand Russell, one of the leading peace activists of the last century, as an example of someone with no ideals highlights the hollowness of that argument.

These are some of the roadblocks in relating conscience to sin.  The route around those roadblocks discussed by the authors referenced in end-note 20 will be the subject of the next blog post on chapter 1.  Meanwhile, because I am an existentialist even though I don’t believe conscience is that special for being right with God, check out this BrainPicker post on how to form a conscience that works for you.

Metaphyics as a Guide to Morals    technological societyBertrand Russell A Political Life

We are reading one chapter per month, starting with chapter 1 in February.  Read the kick-off post for this series.

Endnote 20 references:
A long work by Marilyn McCord Adams is referenced.  Here is a 15 minute interview with her on Philosophy Bites.
If you have JSTOR access, you can get these referenced articles:
Attfield, D.G. (1984, June). The morality of sin. Religious Studies. 20(2):227-237
Mitchell, B. (1984, June). How is the concept of sin related to the concept of moral wrongdoing? Religious Studies. 20(2):165-173
Dalfoerth, I. (1984, June). How is the concept of sin related to the concept of moral wrongdoing? Religious Studies. 20(2):175-189

11FEB2012: Added link to kick-off post.

222 Responses so far.

  1. d72e cheap prices is uk

    is online from italy

    acheter is mastercard

  2. d72e forum is moins cher

    is nachnahme is

    we choice herbal is

  3. d72e where to be is in luton

    is migliore

    is 100 dosi

  4. d72e wirkung von is

    http://ph-07314-2-1.com/ – costo di is

    canadianis

  5. 7cee venta cialis alicante

    http://ph-07314-3-0.com/

    cialis non funziona pi

  6. d72e lilly is 20 mg 12 stuc

    como comprar is online

    is non prescription needed

  7. 7cee comprar cialis bolivia

    comprar cialis online portugal

    to buy cheap cialis uk 100mg

  8. Rannevsom says:

    sell viagra online affiliate

  9. Rannevsom says:

    men health viagra

  10. Rannevsom says:

    where can i buy viagra tablet

  11. Rannevsom says:

    viagra frauen online kaufen

  12. d72e wholesale is suppliers uk

    female be is

    look here cheap is canada

  13. descuentos en is

    6741 time is dosage

  14. a useing is

    6741 be is wholesale

  15. be is through paypal

    6741 r1000eady tabs is

  16. 7cee viagra france pharmacy

    http://ph-07314-3-0.com/

    only today viagra aus usa

  17. d72e precio de is en costa rica

    http://ph-07314-3-1.com/

    be is in argentina

  18. d72e online is soft india

    http://ph-07314-3-1.com/

    is tablets usage

  19. 69a6 the best dose of viagra

    [url=http://viagraqlki.com/]cherche acheter viagra[/url]
    cialis viagra ogame levitr

    coupon viagra free

  20. d72e usefull link online is uk

    http://ph-07314-3-1.com/

    enter site usa is

  21. d72e wirkung von is bodybuildin

    http://ph-07314-3-1.com/

    vente is mg

  22. d72e natural is drug stores

    be is

    is for sale adelaide

  23. Rannevsom says:

    viagra uae price

  24. Rannevsom says:

    click here viagra soft

  25. Rannevsom says:

    dirrections for use of is

  26. Rannevsom says:

    viagra purchase in uk

  27. Rannevsom says:

    33 viagra order online

  28. Rannevsom says:

    can i cut 50 mg is in half

  29. Rannevsom says:

    viagra sildenafil citrate 50mg

  30. Rannevsom says:

    kosten pro dosis fr viagra

  31. Rannevsom says:

    viagra necesita receta

  32. Rannevsom says:

    viagra for sale cork

  33. Rannevsom says:

    the best site viagra oral

  34. Rannevsom says:

    barato viagra suave

  35. Rannevsom says:

    only now 50mg viagra uk cheap

  36. Rannevsom says:

    viagra generico costo

  37. Rannevsom says:

    symptoms of overdose in viagra

  38. Rannevsom says:

    su pillola viagra

  39. Rannevsom says:

    rapid heart viagra

  40. Rannevsom says:

    acquistare viagra parafarmacia

  41. Rannevsom says:

    in tijuana viagra pharmacy buy

  42. Rannevsom says:

    click now viagra sales online

  43. Rannevsom says:

    tomar viagra mujeres

  44. Rannevsom says:

    viagra online rosario

  45. Rannevsom says:

    teachers union viagra

  46. Rannevsom says:

    apotik yang jual viagra

  47. Rannevsom says:

    is en los jovene

  48. Rannevsom says:

    viagra safe pills

  49. Rannevsom says:

    acheter viagra le moins cher

  50. Rannevsom says:

    buying viagra in macau

  51. Rannevsom says:

    how com viagra cost so much

  52. Rannevsom says:

    click here viagra one a day

  53. d72e are at is pills good

    http://ph-07314-3-1.com/

    is generique 100mg

  54. Rannevsom says:

    only for you viagra in canada

  55. Rannevsom says:

    does rush limbaugh use viagra

  56. Rannevsom says:

    order viagra online dk

  57. Rannevsom says:

    viagra canada law

  58. Rannevsom says:

    recommended site viagra uk

  59. Rannevsom says:

    acheter viagra en suisse

  60. Rannevsom says:

    where to buy herbal viagra

  61. d72e campioni di is

    click now female is cheap

  62. Rannevsom says:

    canada is canada cheap

  63. Rannevsom says:

    viagra cialis simili

  64. Rannevsom says:

    site sur pour achat viagra

  65. Rannevsom says:

    the viagra buy in

  66. Rannevsom says:

    just try is for ed

  67. 7cee female pink viagra 100mg pills

    viagra cheap

    refill discounts viagra

  68. Rannevsom says:

    be cheap female is

  69. Rannevsom says:

    viagra effetti durata

  70. 7cee buy viagra wholesale

    vente viagra mg

    the best dose of viagra

  71. Rannevsom says:

    viagra levitra differenze

  72. Rannevsom says:

    natural viagra alternatives

  73. Rannevsom says:

    brand viagra 100mg cheap

  74. Rannevsom says:

    be is online free

  75. Rannevsom says:

    viagra red bull juntos

  76. Rannevsom says:

    just try viagra for ed

  77. Rannevsom says:

    levitra 20 mg o viagra

  78. Rannevsom says:

    commander du viagra en suisse

  79. Rannevsom says:

    watch viagra blue online

  80. Rannevsom says:

    viagra kaufen apothek

  81. Rannevsom says:

    wirkstoff is beipackzettel

  82. Rannevsom says:

    price viagra in india

  83. Rannevsom says:

    viagra how to use it

  84. Rannevsom says:

    viagra cialis einnahme

  85. d72e is price reduction canada

    is online

    levitra is economico

  86. Rannevsom says:

    viagra without a doctor

  87. Rannevsom says:

    viagras sans ordonnance

  88. Rannevsom says:

    irlanda viagra barata

  89. Rannevsom says:

    can heart patition take viagra

  90. Rannevsom says:

    viagra vendita on lin

  91. Rannevsom says:

    viagra buy uk 50mg

  92. Rannevsom says:

    cipla viagra stores

  93. 7cee viagra trial sample

    http://ph-07314-2-0.com/ – viagra cheap

    products like viagra

  94. Rannevsom says:

    tarif viagra tarifs viagra

  95. Rannevsom says:

    viagra from indian company

  96. Rannevsom says:

    generic viagra sale usa

  97. Rannevsom says:

    something better than viagra

  98. d72e is ato diferenca

    http://ph-07314-2-1.com/ – is

    farmaco is prezzo

  99. Rannevsom says:

    is red bull juntos

  100. Rannevsom says:

    kwikmed coupon viagra

  101. Rannevsom says:

    buy real brand viagra

  102. Rannevsom says:

    viagra dosage men

  103. d72e at is details

    http://ph-07314-2-1.com/ – where is at is made

    generique is en france

  104. Rannevsom says:

    is viagra legal in malaysia

  105. Rannevsom says:

    canada viagra canada cheap

  106. Rannevsom says:

    teachers union is

  107. 7cee viagra fast quick uk

    http://ph-07314-3-0.com/

    viagra al sicuro non costoso

  108. Rannevsom says:

    viagra psychischer strung

  109. Rannevsom says:

    riga viagra cialis levitra

  110. Rannevsom says:

    billige is online apotheke

  111. Rannevsom says:

    viagrakaufen 100mg

  112. Rannevsom says:

    viagra no prescription paypal

  113. Rannevsom says:

    viagra billig keine vorschrift

  114. Rannevsom says:

    why to take viagra

  115. Rannevsom says:

    viagra sildenafil tabs

  116. Rannevsom says:

    look here buying viagra online

  117. Rannevsom says:

    is in toronto office

  118. Rannevsom says:

    viagra generic drug

  119. Rannevsom says:

    buy female viagra without rx

  120. Rannevsom says:

    cheap viagra paypal payment

  121. Rannevsom says:

    viagra tablets best price

  122. Rannevsom says:

    viagra gnrique inde

  123. Rannevsom says:

    viagra pricelist

  124. Rannevsom says:

    viagra sales usa

  125. Rannevsom says:

    achat viagra arnaque

  126. Rannevsom says:

    viagra e cialis onlin

  127. Rannevsom says:

    cialis y viagra diferencia

  128. 7cee ordering viagra from mexico

    cialis ou viagra 5 mg

  129. Rannevsom says:

    online sales of viagra

  130. Rannevsom says:

    viagra cost 50mg vs 100mg

  131. 7cee viagra achat en ligne canada

    coupon viagra free

  132. Rannevsom says:

    viagra quanto costa

  133. Rannevsom says:

    try it generic viagra mexico

  134. Rannevsom says:

    i recommend cheap is

  135. d72e is 100mg prix pharmaci

    spanische apotheke is

  136. Rannevsom says:

    online viagra france

  137. Rannevsom says:

    memenucom buy viagra mexico

  138. Rannevsom says:

    viagra en los jovene

  139. Rannevsom says:

    wirkstoff viagra beipackzettel

  140. Rannevsom says:

    viagra young people

  141. Rannevsom says:

    europa viagra barata

  142. Rannevsom says:

    viagra overdose 200mg

  143. d72e is dose correta

    is bestellen empfehlung

  144. Rannevsom says:

    should i take cialis or viagra

  145. Rannevsom says:

    comprare online viagra

  146. Rannevsom says:

    is e nitroderivati

  147. Rannevsom says:

    generic viagra on a plane

  148. Rannevsom says:

    google low price is

  149. Rannevsom says:

    is without a doctor

  150. Rannevsom says:

    only here viagra pharmacy

  151. d72e is side effects pictures

    is at tablets

  152. d72e is pfizer price in germany

    generique is en france

    is fast quick uk

  153. commande is 2

    df7f is a 20 anni

  154. 7cee cialis tu medico

    http://ph-07314-2-0.com/ – indio cialis genrico

    just try cialis pfizer online

  155. 7cee cialis online a basso costo

    http://ph-07314-2-0.com/ – generic v brand name cialis

    just try cialis pfizer online

  156. 7cee cialis 20mg retail price

    http://ph-07314-2-0.com/ – cialis cheap

    canada cialis sale

  157. 7cee wow look it cialis buy

    http://ph-07314-2-0.com/ – buy cialis online

    where to find cialis

  158. d72e is 20mg emramed

    http://ph-07314-2-1.com/ – is dosage sale

    is 20mg tablets cheap

  159. d72e el is rebaj ventas

    http://ph-07314-2-1.com/ – is online

    is no script

  160. d72e comprar is temuco

    http://ph-07314-2-1.com/ – is online

    is take best results

  161. 7cee cialis en exceso

    http://ph-07314-3-0.com/

    pillola di cialis

  162. 7cee visit web site cialis 5 mg

    http://ph-07314-3-0.com/

    cialis preisvergleich generika

  163. visit web site is 5 mg

    df7f is erection penis

  164. is blogs

    df7f only here at is pill

  165. d72e is online aus holland

    5mg is costco

  166. 38cd is en exceso

    venta is en andorr

  167. 56b7 the price of cialis in the uk

    cialis generic

    15mg of cialis

  168. isnde eventi 2014

    37a0 dosi di pillola di is

  169. natural is foods for men

    37a0 is is for women

  170. 38cd vente is sans ordonnanc

    http://ph-90599-2-1.com/ – at is online

    pink is side effects

  171. 56b7 en ucuz viagra 100 mg

    http://ph-90599-3-0.com/

    viagra indien bestellt

  172. 56b7 natural viagra foods for men

    http://ph-90599-3-0.com/

    cheap viagra usa

  173. 38cd is men pills

    http://ph-90599-3-1.com/

    price of is in pakistan

  174. 56b7 generic viagra soft tab fast

    viagra vs cialis drinking vs

  175. vendita is in svizzer

    37a0 is al giorno

  176. 38cd ordering is online forum

    is pour homme pharmacie

  177. best at pharma is

    37a0 is pfize

  178. 56b7 click here brand viagra canada

    buy viagra online

    the best choice viagra paypal

  179. 38cd being is cozumel

    being is cozumel

    where to be is in saudi

  180. 38cd cheap is pfizer

    be online securely is

    ordering is online forum

  181. Rannevsom says:

    uk viagra online using paypal

  182. Rannevsom says:

    viagra generic japan

  183. 56b7 pfizer australia viagra

    http://ph-90599-2-0.com/ – mailorder viagra

    viagra approved

  184. Rannevsom says:

    avis is is levitr

  185. Rannevsom says:

    buy maestro viagra

  186. cvs caremark is

    0584 we like it is in spain

  187. 38cd be is soft mg online

    http://ph-90599-2-1.com/ – is barato windsor

    is mechanism

  188. 38cd just try is daily prices

    http://ph-90599-2-1.com/ – online is

    is without prescription eu

  189. 38cd at where be to is

    http://ph-90599-2-1.com/ – is cheap

    is open

  190. 56b7 cialis mt canada

    http://ph-90599-3-0.com/

    cialis prix discoun

  191. 56b7 cialis deutschland kaufen

    http://ph-90599-3-0.com/

    kanada beste preise cialis

  192. 56b7 achat de pilules de cialis

    http://ph-90599-3-0.com/

    cialis no falla

  193. 38cd usefull link what is is

    http://ph-90599-3-1.com/

    pfizer is online

  194. 38cd is no falla

    http://ph-90599-3-1.com/

    is free trial australia

  195. 56b7 best cialis 5mg prices

    cialis pas generique

Leave a Reply